I warned you last time (here) that I started thinking about some things in Ham Radio…

Years ago I selected a stack of carefully treasured QSL cards, filled in the requiered documents and took the works to the ARRL DXCC Field Checker for Belgium. I paid a fee and received a certificate that is now framed and a part of the shack: “DXCC CW”. A while later I jumped on the LotW-bandwagon and got an endorsement for another few dozen entities. Honnestly: achieving basic DXCC means squat.  It’s easy. Even 250 entitites CW only is easy. It’s easy with a setup like mine that is. Running QRP with an indoor antenna might be a bigger challenge.

A little harder but still quite manageable is 5 Band DXCC. Since I put up the 80m vertical and added a touch of QRO, even on 80m there is nothing hard about working 100 entities from here in EU. I have lost track of the score in paper cards let alone finding the cards. So thanks to LotW one day I achieved 5B DXCC CW. Nothing I consider special and I didn’t specifically work towards it – it just happenend along the way. And I was glad I discovered it, as you can read in my “5BDXCC in CW” post a few years ago.

So why not apply for the 5BDXCC award through the LotW system? A few clicks, a few bucks – et voilà. Not so it seems. I didn’t find a way to do this in one easy move. So I quit looking. Then I came across AE5X‘s post called: “Economics of DXing – the $200 5B-DXCC“. I quote:

For 5B-DXCC, the ARRL requires such an applicant to apply (and pay for) 5 separate DXCC certificates. You can then pay an additional fee for the plaque to adorn your I Love Me wall. The 5 certs cost $135, the plaque is $65. At first that sounded expensive since everything is virtual.

AE5X concludes that 200 US Dollars for LotW 5B DXCC is a bargain compared to ‘the old skool paper QSL alternative’ which takes longer and sending direct cards to rare entities with return postage for a few hundred cards is much more expensive. He’s right when you look at it his way.

ON5ZO's Alternative DXCC Wallpaper

ON5ZO's Alternative DXCC Wallpaper

But I look at it ON5ZO’s way, of course. 200 US $ for what? For another paper on my wall that apart from myself hardly anyone ever sees? As a written proof of me having 5x 100 entities confirmed on the 5 regular HF bands? My LotW DXCC standings table already shows it and is as good as a written proof! And a 5BDXCC plaque is something that you actually buy. I can go to the awards and trophy shop in the next town and have myself engraved a plaque for whatever achievement.
Furthermore I have a rule about money spent on the hobby. Every possible purchase or investment is checked against these simple conditions: “Will it bring me more DX? Will it improve my score in contesting? Will it enhance my fun on the bands?”. Well: 200 $ for 5B DXCC fails miserably on all three.

17 Responses to 5B DXCC: expensive wallpaper, bad investment

  • Bas PE4BAS says:

    A good one….I like the certificate. Think I will make one myself ;-) 73, Bas

  • John AE5X says:

    Awesome – I think I’ll do the same! Who needs the ARRL’s (or any other entity’s) blessing?

    • Janu says:

      Jeff that’s an important point about the nuebmr of contacts. If I remember correctly, some of the earlier contests had rules that really limited the nuebmr of contacts you could make. Now, a multi-two station here in the States could garner 7,000 contacts in a weekend. With all the associated QSL costs.Nice addition. Thanks.

  • Mike says:

    Very good point about the cost and how you at your shack justify the outlay of money. As for me the only DXCC I am going for is the 75th Jubilee award. But for me it may be a bit difficult as I am QRP and am running an attic dipole. Up to this point I am at 68 countries worked thanks to the ARRL CW contest that just pasted.

  • John K3TN says:

    I’ll give you the opposing viewpoint, as I paid for both 5BWAS *and* 5BDXCC certificates *and* plaques via LotW:

    My rule on expenditures: I work pretty hard to earn my money and pay the rent, the grocery bills, for kids needs, family needs, ever increasing costs of gas for the cars and oil for the furnace, save for retirement, etc. At the tiny end of this funnel of money, a bit trickles out that I spend on fun for myself.

    I became a ham in 1969, and have never had more than a wire antenna or vertical up in the air. I’ve always loved talking to people far away and tracking DX countries was always fun but I didn’t even get DXCC until 1987 – I just looked at the cards coming in from the bureau until I had 100 different countries. That certificate was very cool – I enjoyed receiving it in the mail and it was worth the $12 or whatever it cost.

    I did what the Japanese call “the long QRT” from 1996 to 2009 as family and work took precedence. I got back on in 2009 and LotW was an amazing thing to me – I could actually see progress towards 5BDXCC and I had a blast chasing band-countries and band-states for 5BWAS – I never even tracked it before. LotW didn’t cost me anything to use – an amazing thing.

    In December 2011 I pushed my 10M total above 100 and got the last few states on 10 as well – 5BDXCC (actually 8B!) and 5BWAS (actually 6B with 160m) at essentially the same time. When I was a novice operator, those awards seemed to me to be the apex of operating, only achieved by old timers with huge amplifiers and huge antennas. Especially those wooden plaques! Getting there will wires and towards the end small amps was a very satisfying achievement to me.

    When I figured out the cost of getting the ARRL certificate and plaques, three things went through my mind:

    1. Yikes!
    2. LotW is free – I’d rather spend the money on supporting LotW than send most other things I could support in ham radio.
    3. Only I will see those plaques in my basement, and the certificates will go in a drawer but I’ve always wanted them on my wall.

    Points 2 and 3 outweighed point 1. On point 2, I have no guarantee any of my $$ actually will help LotW get better, but I think some of it will.

    On Point 3: I’m didn’t get the plaques for anyone else but me to look at! Every time I look at those plaques I think of 40 years ago working my first ON on 40M CW and how exotic that felt – and then think about checking LotW and seeing that 5B4 10M QSL that put me over the top for 5BDXCC, and how much fun that was – the $$ spent still feel worth it.

    Also, when I’m trying to work 3C0E and hear the QRM on his frequency, and the pileup that never listens and all the other sad aspects that pollute DXing, I look at those plaques and think “serenity now, serenity now” (a “Seinfeld” reference that may be NA-specific..) and it keeps me from pulling the plug and going on another long QRT!

    73, John K3TN

  • You’re totally right Frank, I might do it myself this way.
    CQ fees however are not expensive, I have a few WAZ awards (chasing WAZ RTTY and 5BWAZ now) and they came for like 16 US$ when I wasn’t having CQ membership, I think it’s now 12US$ if you are.

    I’m now aiming especially for 5BWAZ (entry level, 150) with this stupid piece of wire I have and 100W, that’ll keep me busy for another while! (134 zones confirmed)

  • Gust says:

    Hi Frank,
    I know WAZ is more difficult but that’s where the fun lies and I have to be honest, I’m pretty proud having WAZ CW on the wall here. That CQ awards will be through LoTW I knew about, alas WPX is first in the row, I hope that the WAZ program follows quickly.

    I guess you’re right on the wire, worked some really nice DX the last few years including pretty rare ones in the Pacific.
    You never know what will happen.

    73, good DX.

    • ON5ZO says:

      I did the check: I’m missing 5 zones on 80m. That will be the hardest I guess, with stuff like KL7, KH6 and deep pacific rarities. Once I heard a loud and workable KH7 there, but it was in ARRL CW of course!

      DW4WIN also tells me I only have 39/40 on 10m which is strange: although I worked a few z2 on ten, it says I’m missing zone 2!

      All 40 zones worked on 15,20,30 and 40. Only a few missing on 17 and 12. Maybe in 2024 when cycle 25 peaks?

      We’ll see what LotW says once it supports the WAZ award.

      You say: “You never know what will happen.“, well that’s exactly what the fun is. Sometimes nothing, sometimes the best DX. Of course it’s more fun to work DX than to work nothing. :-)

  • Congratulations, love that certificate, still miss some stuff on 80m then will make one too ;-)

    73 see you on contests

    • ON5ZO says:

      Someone even sent me a blank original ARRL DXCC template! I don’t know where he got it from, but you just need to add your name and call with some graphic editing software ‘et voilà’ :-)

      • Jim says:

        Where can I get that template? Sure would like to have one. I am one of those totally bummed out with the ARRL 5BDXCC award. Sounds like a cash cow to me.

        • ON5ZO says:

          Jim, a friend sent it by mail and I thought I saved the attachement but it seems I didn’t. QRX – I asked to send it again.

          • Jim says:

            QSL. I did get the regular DXCC certificate, which I do have. But this process to submit all 5 bands at $31 for the first and $12 for the other 4 and then another $31 for the 5BDXCC is not something I want to do plus endorsement costs. But current counts are:
            80 = 118
            40 = 107
            20 = 116
            15 = 114
            10 = 103

            and 30 = 202, 17 = 155. Sure seems like enough to me.

            I’ve given up ever getting this from the ARRL. Big waste of $$, IMO.

  • DJ7EC says:

    Well, meanwhile I don´t even care about getting the QSL from a rare one. I just put them down in my log and enjoy. I don´t need the ARRL to tell me that I´ve worked them all. The last thing I would spend 200 bucks for is a piece of paper ….

  • Bruce Manning NJ3K says:

    Lots of very good points. I have looked at DXCC and any Amateur award differently. I have a small station, one dipole about 200 feet on a side and fed with 450 ohm ladder line, also a inverted “L” for 160 with about 4000 feet of radials. I operate just 100 watts and CW only. Ok now saying all of that, my feelings are if I can work DXCC with a small station I feel pretty proud of what I have done. In fact I have worked 9 band DXCC (160 – 10) all CW all with the 2 antennas and 100 watts. I have 317 countries with 312 current countries. Also I have DX Challenge and stand at 1460 confirmed and 1536 worked, for the next award there Yes all the certificates and plaques cost a lot but it’s a one time cost. Having been licensed for 41 years, if you spread the cost out it’s not too bad.
    73
    Bruce NJ3K

    • ON5ZO says:

      Obtaining DXCC with a 241m high tower, a tribander and QRO = easy.
      Doing the same with 100W and modest low non-resonant antennas = harder.
      DXCC with QRP and indoor antennas = very hard.

      73!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>